
I was intrigued when listening to NPR do an article on leaders from the ANC, African National Congress, leaving to form a new opposition party in South Africa (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=95924786).
Please listen to the link for a better understanding of the what's been happening. My comment is in relation to one piece of this story. A dissident party member describes why he has decided to leave the party, that the ANC no longer lives by its long tradition of fighting tribalism. His words were something like...a Zulu party member wants to make T-Shirts displaying his tribe's emblem and the ANC is OK with this. They did not fight it.
Please listen to the link for a better understanding of the what's been happening. My comment is in relation to one piece of this story. A dissident party member describes why he has decided to leave the party, that the ANC no longer lives by its long tradition of fighting tribalism. His words were something like...a Zulu party member wants to make T-Shirts displaying his tribe's emblem and the ANC is OK with this. They did not fight it.
My first instinct was to put this comment into an American context. I thought, "why would it not be OK for a Zulu to make a T-Shirt displaying the emblems of his tribe?" My thought process followed two perspectives.
1. Making a Zulu oriented T-Shirt, from an American perspective, would be like someone who was Japanese wearing a shirt with their country's flag on it. Or a Latina, wearing the colors of Puerto Rico or Cuba or Mexico. Or even the Rastafarian who wears a yellow, green and red shirt with Bob Marley on the front. I mean showing people who you are and where you come from has become a source of price for most Americans. I thought, "Why would you not want a Zulu to display his or her own heritage? Isn't being Zulu a huge part of their identity? To take that person's identity away and make them just ANC, is that truly democratic? Wouldn't their be a lot of grief and sadness related to the process of wiping out tribalism in South Africa? And haven't we seen in America that when a person's identity is taken away, we are left with generations of individuals who, not knowing who they are and where they come from, lead reckless unproductive lives?"
2. When I think of Rwanda and Darfur and how the tribes try to wipe each other out because of grudges that go untended; when I think of all the atrocities committed in the name of one tribe or the other, I begin to see tribes as more like gangs. From this perspective, to wear a tribal T-Shirt might be more closely akin to wearing gang colors or gang signs.
But, I think there must be a compromise between these two perspectives. Somehow America has gotten there, I think. We are the great melting pot. And not a day goes by when I as an American am reminded of the benefits of cultural and racial diversity. Rather than wiping out the identity of a person by eliminating tribalism, hadn't we ought to focus on forgiveness and peace between the tribes? How would a government like the ANC go about quenching the hot tribal hatred without stripping a tribe of its identity?
I'd love to know your thoughts.










